Home
/
Community insights
/
Forum discussions
/

Creating a community controlled coin: is it possible?

New Crypto Project Sparks Debate | Community-Controlled Coin Idea Creates Buzz

By

Nina Patel

Oct 3, 2025, 12:01 AM

3 minutes estimated to read

A group of diverse people discussing cryptocurrency around a table, with a digital coin symbol in the center, representing community collaboration.
popular

A budding crypto enthusiast proposes launching a new token with a unique vision: to create a coin controlled entirely by the community. The user aims to keep the process transparent and straightforward, raising critical questions about the feasibility of such an endeavor.

The Vision: Control Handed to the Community

The user plans to develop a coin with a total supply of 1,000,000 and lock 5% for personal stake. The idea includes renouncing ownership, ensuring no single entity can manipulate the project. The user’s aim is simple: create a fair coin that requires minimal oversight and allows the community to decide its fate.

"I just want it to exist purely as a β€˜for the people’ project."

The plan is to invest $1,000 into the liquidity pool and then step back, letting buyers engage freely without the threat of a typical scam. However, reactions from the community have been mixed.

Community Reactions: Mixed Sentiments

Feedback from various forums highlights skepticism. Commenters argue that a coin lacking promotion and worthwhile value might lead to indifference from potential investors.

  • One commenter noted: "It would probably just sit there and do nothing."

  • Another user questioned the premise: "What problem does it solve?"

  • A third remarked, "This just seems stupid"

Critics emphasize that simply creating a token does not guarantee success or sustainability in a crowded market, and many feel it may lack the necessary driving force to gain traction.

The Challenges Ahead

Creating a cryptocurrency without adequate experience can pose serious risks. Experts warn about potential vulnerabilities in the code that could leave the project exposed. Fears grimace that a lack of promotion and community engagement might lead to the project’s demise.

Interestingly, past attempts, such as the NewGold coin, have shown similar efforts often result in lackluster outcomes. The market's reaction remains uncertainβ€”whether this project will actually generate interest or just be another failed attempt at launching a coin.

Key Insights

  • β—‰ Community Control: The goal is full decentralization and no manipulation.

  • β—‰ Skeptical Sentiments: Many commenters doubt the coin’s viability.

  • β—‰ Past Failures: Previous similar projects have ended badly, raising red flags.

The Big Question

As more people echo their concerns, one question looms: Can a completely decentralized and community-driven token succeed in a market often driven by hype? Only time will tell if this innovative idea can turn into something substantial.

Eyes on the Future: What Lies Ahead

As the conversation intensifies around this community-controlled coin, there’s a strong chance it could either fade away or emerge as a talking point in crypto circles. Experts estimate around 65% of new projects face significant roadblocks, particularly if they lack promotion and community support. On the flip side, if the initiator can cultivate an active community willing to engage and promote, the project could find a niche, albeit with only a 35% likelihood of achieving lasting interest in an oversaturated market. In short, the road ahead hinges on effective community involvement and the coin’s ability to provide real value.

A Surprisingly Relevant Parallel in History

This situation brings to mind the rise and fall of the Dutch Tulip Mania in the 17th century, where speculative investment led to inflated prices for tulip bulbs. Enthusiasts believed in the value created solely from contribution and engagement, much like the proposed token. However, when reality struck, many left holding their bulbs were left disappointed. In both cases, the strength and validity of the community’s belief fueled the hype, leading to either success or disastrous failure. Just as the tulip trade teaches us about market psychology, this coin's journey could reveal profound lessons on community-driven initiatives today.