Home
/
Market analysis
/
Market cap overview
/

Why mstr's bitcoin purchase model raises eyebrows

MicroStrategy’s Stock Dilemma | Bitcoin Holdings Questioned

By

Nina Patel

May 22, 2025, 08:36 AM

Edited By

Marco Rossi

2 minutes estimated to read

Illustration showing MSTR stock and Bitcoin coins, symbolizing the company's investment strategy

MicroStrategy, a major player in the crypto space, is stirring conversation as it issues new stock to purchase Bitcoin. With a market cap of $111 billion and Bitcoin holdings valued at $66 billion, many are questioning the company's strategy and its sustainability amid increased competition.

What's Happening?

MicroStrategy is maneuvering into uncharted financial waters by selling shares to buy more Bitcoin. Some believe this could be a lucrative model, but questions loom about its long-term viability. For every $1,000 invested in MicroStrategy, investors effectively gain only $660 worth of Bitcoin.

Concerns from Investors

Interestingly, many in the community wonder why more individuals and companies haven't adopted MicroStrategy's model. One commented, "What would stop me from selling short MicroStrategy and buying Bitcoin?" The sentiment reflects a growing anxiety about the disparity between MicroStrategy’s stock price and its underlying Bitcoin assets.

Financial Backing and Strategies

In response to these concerns, hedge funds are reportedly buying MicroStrategy stock to hedge risks associated with convertible bonds. One user observed, "It's a game of musical chairs," implying the fragility of MicroStrategy's strategy tied to market volatility.

Several comments highlight significant disparities between company value and market cap. A user pointed out, "Balance sheet assets don’t equal market cap," emphasizing the need for a rooted understanding of financial health beyond asset value. Another noted that for MicroStrategy to justify its market cap, it would require around $11 billion in profits, far from its current revenue of $500 million.

"Saylor is doing the right move here" - one user reflects, referencing the CEO's aggressive Bitcoin purchases at market highs.

The Bigger Picture

Critics argue that MicroStrategy is diluting shareholder value. By constantly issuing stock to buy Bitcoin, the model may generate immediate gains but lacks substantial revenue pathways. This challenges the notion of MSTR as a stable investment as opposed to a perpetual cycle of buying and selling in the crypto market.

Key Insights πŸ“Š

  • β–³ MicroStrategy sells new stocks to boost Bitcoin holdings.

  • β–½ Concerns arise over sustainability as market saturation grows.

  • β€» "Companies' market value is based on much more than their balance sheet" - a comment points out the complexity of valuation.

Final Thoughts

As MicroStrategy continues to navigate its crypto strategy, investors are left balancing potential gains against risk. Will this model catch on, or will it ultimately unravel under market pressures? Time will tell.

Market Predictions for MicroStrategy's Future

There's a strong chance that MicroStrategy will continue its stock issuance to build Bitcoin holdings in the near term. Investors might see fluctuations but a potential 20% increase in Bitcoin value could encourage more companies to adopt similar strategies. However, many analysts predict that long-term sustainability remains uncertain, with around 60% likelihood this model could face significant challenges in 2026 due to market saturation and investor skepticism.

Unlikely Lessons from the Dot-com Boom

A less obvious parallel can be drawn from the dot-com boom in the late 1990s. Many companies rushed to go public, offering high valuations without sustainable business models. Some became giants, but others collapsed under unrealistic expectations. Much like MicroStrategy, those firms chased short-term gains while ignoring foundational stability, leading to a shake-out as the market matured. This suggests that while bold strategies can pay off, they also come with risks that could reshape the landscape entirely.