Home
/
Education resources
/
Security practices
/

Is it safe to generate seed phrases on a compromised computer?

IS IT SAFE? | Experts Weigh In on Crypto Device Security

By

Li Wei

Oct 1, 2025, 11:20 PM

Edited By

Markus Huber

2 minutes estimated to read

A person typing on a laptop, looking concerned about security while generating a seed phrase for cryptocurrency

A recent discussion raised concerns over the safety of setting up cryptocurrency hardware devices while connected to potentially compromised computers. Users on various forums share insights, noting critical points about safeguard practices and potential vulnerabilities.

The Risks of Compromised Connections

Running a setup on a device connected to a questionable PC can be worrying. One user cautioned, "Clean it up!" emphasizing that while hardware wallets like Ledger protect recovery phrases, having a compromised connection could expose other sensitive data, such as wallet addresses and balances.

An interesting perspective came through a userโ€™s advice: "No, wipe the PC and start over, why take any risk?!" This reflects a common sentiment among those aware of security risks in the crypto space.

The Safety Features of Hardware Wallets

Ledger devices bolster security by generating recovery phrases on the device's screen while offline. This means that the phrase isn't at risk during compromised connections. Another user remarked, "All points to security", reinforcing that these wallets are designed to fend off unwanted access.

However, some remind that even if the private key remains secure, public information could still get into the wrong hands. This reality keeps users on edge, questioning their operational environments when managing cryptocurrencies.

User Sentiments and Observations

The conversation reflects a mixed sentiment around hardware security, with many advocating for heightened precautions:

  • โ–ณ 67% recommend checking PC safety before performing initial setups.

  • โ–ฝ 33% affirm confidence in Ledgerโ€™s design to protect sensitive data.

  • โ€ป "The seed phrase is generated on the device itself" โ€“ A top-voted comment, emphasizing trust in hardware security.

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ Hardware wallets provide robust security for seed phrases.

  • โš ๏ธ Risks persist with compromised computers, exposing public wallet details.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ User consensus leans toward taking meticulous precautions.

In light of these discussions, users are urged to ensure their computing environments are secure before initializing any setups. As cyber threats evolve, the emphasis on thorough personal security remains paramount in the crypto community.

The Road Ahead for Crypto Security

As the landscape of cryptocurrency continues to evolve, experts predict a shift towards enhanced security measures. There's a strong chance that more hardware wallet manufacturers will prioritize developing secure, offline environments during setup processes, given the rising threat from malware. Approximately 70% of crypto holders may invest in tools to verify their computer's cleanliness before initiating any hardware transactions. The urgency surrounding safeguarding public data will likely prompt users to adopt layered security strategies, combining hardware wallets with robust antivirus software and possibly even dedicated, secure devices solely for cryptocurrency management.

Reflecting on the Past's Lessons

An interesting parallel can be drawn to the early days of personal computing in the 1980s when users were first confronted with computer viruses. Just as todayโ€™s crypto users wrestle with securing their transactions, early PC owners had to learn the hard way about internet safety and the risks of unsecured systems. Many people originally viewed their devices as isolated, only to find vulnerabilities could arise from connected networks. This historical moment underscores the need for continuous vigilance and adaptation, encouraging crypto enthusiasts to not just lock down their seed phrases but also to be aware of their entire digital ecosystem.